Google has issued a formal apology to the Indian government and Prime Minister Narendra Modi over misleading and unreliable responses generated by its AI platform, Gemini. The controversy emerged when Gemini was criticized for providing unsubstantiated information about Prime Minister Modi, raising concerns about the accuracy and bias within AI-generated content.
The Minister of State for IT & Electronics, Rajeev Chandrasekhar, disclosed that the Indian government had sought an explanation from Google regarding the discrepancies observed in Gemini’s outputs. In response, Google acknowledged the issues with Gemini, admitting the platform’s unreliability and extending an apology to Prime Minister Modi and the Indian authorities. This incident unfolds amid India’s tightened scrutiny over AI platforms, with the government indicating plans to introduce permits for AI operations within the country. Chandrasekhar stressed the importance of AI platforms adhering to the respect and legality due to Indian consumers, hinting at the legal consequences under IT and criminal laws for spreading false information.
Further complicating matters for Google, Gemini was accused of displaying racial bias and historical inaccuracies. A particularly contentious issue arose when the AI chatbot reportedly declined to generate images of white individuals and inaccurately portrayed historical white figures as people of color. These allegations have led to widespread criticism and calls for Google CEO Sundar Pichai’s resignation.
In the wake of the backlash, Google took immediate action to disable Gemini’s human image generation feature. Sundar Pichai described the error as “completely unacceptable” and committed to addressing the issues raised. Despite Google’s efforts to mitigate the situation, calls for Pichai’s resignation have intensified. Analysts Ben Thompson and Mark Shmulik have voiced their opinion on the necessity for leadership changes at Google, suggesting that overcoming these challenges may require new management direction, potentially implicating CEO Sundar Pichai himself.
Thompson highlighted the need for a transformative change within Google, advocating for a leadership overhaul to rectify past mistakes. Similarly, Shmulik questioned the current management team’s capability to steer Google through these tumultuous waters. As Google pledges to refine and improve its AI technologies, the company faces a critical juncture. The controversy underscores the broader challenges facing AI development, including ensuring accuracy, fairness, and the ethical use of technology in a rapidly evolving digital landscape.